Like many expats I too went through the various phases of resettling back in India: ‘touristy’ excitement, disorientation, annoyance and frustration, gradual adaptation and finally bi-culturality that has now allowed me to find my own sense of belonging in what I still consider my hometown, Bangalore.
This is not the Bengaluru I left in 1978. Regular visits I thought had prepared me for the changes, but holidaying and living here are very different. Of course, it is foolish to expect the place to remain unchanged. So many of the people I knew and loved have moved on or moved away, and even those who are here are so far away in terms of distance and traffic, they might as well be in a different city. The city has changed too in its landscape, its unbelievably chaotic traffic, its high-rise buildings and, most of all, its missing trees.
It is no longer a garden city. Yet, there is much to come back to: the wonderful weather, especially for someone coming from the UK; the same warmth and hospitality, although the people are very busy and consequently more stressed; the colourful festivals and ceremonies; and the food – always the food! Yes, I love this place, not blindly, but like the love we bear for our children or even parents whose shortcomings do not make us love them less.
When friends express pride in how Bangalore has developed and how people can live here as well, or even better, than they can abroad, I want to agree – and partly do. But it depends on the interpretation of ‘development’ or ‘progress’. I particularly take pride in the fact that we have clung to democracy by the skin of our teeth when I look around at our neighbours in the subcontinent. But I will be prouder when our political democracy extends to economic and social life, and the divide between the two Indias, or the myriad Indias, is narrowed.
Sadly, there are some things that have hit me hard since my return. Either earlier I did not notice or conditions have worsened. Perhaps both.
There are four things that particularly concern me about our city and our country: rampant corruption that corrodes everything; filth I see even in ‘rich’ layouts like mine; lack of organisation and discipline (not just on the roads); and time-wasting bureaucracy. But what worries me even more are the 3 As: attitude, arrogance and apathy among many who could make a difference. I do see the good that some do, giving freely of their time and energy to make a difference.
But these are the exceptions. For the most part, we are so caught up in keeping up with the Kumars that there seems little time to spare a thought for the less privileged. We have two alarmingly different lifestyles of the haves and the have-nots, but my visits to our schools and colleges for lectures or training lead me to believe many of our “educated” youngsters do not seem to be growing up with an awareness of this shocking inequality.
So what is the answer? Is there one?
Yes. My hope lies in our children, in their upbringing both at home and their early-years education. As a teacher trainer, I believe our teachers should be trained to holistically educate our children live a life with purpose, with the capacity to care – both for their fellow creatures and the environment. Our parents too need to realise this huge responsibility. They hold the future of our children, and consequently our society, in their hands. As an educator, when I visit schools and colleges, I sometimes feel with a sinking heart that we haven’t understood the true meaning of education. It seems to be more about passing exams with top marks, passing interviews and securing jobs or further education abroad. Yes, we want all of these for our children, but we want them also to be responsible and respectable individuals.
Therefore, we need to re-educate our teachers first into becoming inspirational mentors and role-models. Then this awareness can cascade down to our students. Sometimes I lose hope in my own generation to embrace change within themselves and then to make outward change possible. How do we make them care more? It is too late, I think. Old habits die hard, I think. You can’t teach an old dog new tricks, I think.
But when I talk to students in some of the schools and colleges that invite me, I can see the young minds listening, responding and thinking. We connect. Even if 10 out of a 100 can be touched, it is a job well done.
In some of our gatherings, I hear a lot of blame and complaints against our politicians and government. Yes, we are a democracy and therefore it is right that we point fingers where and when accusations are justified. In fact, we must. But I also ache to ask, “So what are you doing to make a difference? Is it not also about individual responsibility and accountability?” Now that I am living here, I had to turn that question around and ask: “What am I doing about it?” My own answer was to work with a small group of friends to do what social service we can. It is a tiny effort, but we are not discouraged. Sky is the limit and we make a start with shaking but unfailing baby steps.
Perhaps we will realise along the way that when we set out to make even a little bit of difference, the biggest difference we end up making is for ourselves.
Rani Rao Innes is the senior partner and lead trainer of Link Communications, a specialized communications skills company based in the UK. She has regularly presented courses and training workshops for private and public business sectors as well as students and teachers in the UK, Belgium, Malaysia, Japan and India. She has also been active in theatre for 30 years and was the director of Canterbury Players in Kent for eight years.
Dear Rani
I must admit each piece you have written has a deeper meaning, it truly sets the reader , as to how can i do my bit to change the three A’s you have so rightly paraphrased . I am truly honored to have a friend like you who constantly worries as to where the future of our country has headed. Most parents treat their children like ATM ( all time marks that makes money) without substance.
Enjoyed reading it.
Perceptive words.
“educate our children live a live with purpose”.. wow.. that is what has been eroded away from our education system over the last three decades.. obviously your deep understanding of society and the importance of education to build a “holistic” is prophetic.. thanks Rani for your contribution.
I enjoyed reading your beautifully reflected sentiments! Thank you! I especially find apathy towards social problems to be a huge issue in India. Somehow they feel that problems surrounding them belong to someone else and hence do nothing about it! I totally agree that there has to be some change in our education system to see change in the generations to come.
Rani, that seemed to come from the heart. Its true that our hope lies in our children and that we as teachers or parents need to play our role with a lot of sincerity, sensitivity and vision.
Sadly, the hustle and bustle of day -to day activities, seems to make our apathy a good excuse for not doing anything.
read that last sentence as ‘ the hustle and bustle of day to day activities seem to provide a good excuse for our apathy’ :))
Beautiful! Timely piece, Rani!
So true, Rani . A little bit of care and concern from us can make a world of a difference for someone. We all need that little smile, that little word of kindness and it does not cost us anything o give these away.
As ever Rani another stimulating article
I particularly like the last 2 paragraphs However I do question the ‘ re education of teachers’ comment
so many teachers in the UK are under enormous pressure to secure good exam results not just from parents but from head teachers who want an ‘ outstanding’ in an ofsted report
I agree that part of teacher training should include your role as a mentor and model for young people however many colleagues have said to me
“I trained as a maths teacher that is my passion but I am not trained to teach students about sex or social responsibility that is the duty of the parents’
True, as a teacher myself, I recognise the enormous pressure of most of our overworked and quite often underpaid teachers. My main concern is with the system itself that puts pressure both on teachers and students to “perform” – a concern shared by so many teachers and students I’ve spoken to here. I was speakig in an Indian context where often the education is techer-focussed and not student-centred. With some exceptions, discussion, debate and critical thinking are not always encouraged and the students have to regurgitate “notes” passively taken down in class, the objective being gaining the highest marks possible. My heart goes out to the teachers and the students. Both schools and parents have to rethink the meaning of education. And yes, teacher training should recognise that the straightjacket of “methodolgies” does not work in every context. Having said this, i do recognise that under such systems, being inspirational teachers is asking a lot.
Very well written and very touching.
So true, we need to re-educate our teachers. Specially the teachers of primary n middle classes must be patient, experinced n educated enough to understand phychology of children. Education’s whole purpose is to recognise the potential of the child n to help it to come out of him. But instead we r giving our children a certain pattern or rather a certain mould and pressurising them to fit or rather take shape of that mould. And i think that’s the rason of 3 As that u’ve mentioned. I think education to b authentic, must be pressure free.
Rani, Such a thought provoking article on republic day–let us BE the change we want to see.
🙂 it feels nice when universe keeps sending me signs just when i seem to need them the most. thanks for this article, Rani. and yes apart from teachers, i feel even parents have a major major role today. Open-ended learning is such a need of the hour. and that has to begin at home before teachers come into picture.
well written Rani. I truly believe change ‘ll come soon as people are becoming more aware. We can’t afford un involvement anymore.